1. Home
  2. Father of the Bride
  3. Daddy's Little Girl
  4. A Little Overprotective, Are Ya?

A Little Overprotective, Are Ya?

The mere mention of your name makes the boyfriends shake. The sound of your voice sends them running. If it were up to you (and your wife), your daughter would be living in an ivory tower. She's much too fragile to handle what the world has to offer, and you, quite frankly, can't bear the thought of her having to suffer through life's tough lessons. You'll take care of her by sheltering her.

Sound familiar? Are you constantly being told that you're way too overprotective? That if you don't cool it, your kids will never know anything about (or be able to handle) real life? Take this little quiz to find out where you fall in the scheme of fatherly surveillance. Be honest. Although many of these questions will refer to your daughter's childhood, you're looking for a pattern of behavior that you might very well be carrying on today without realizing it.

1. As a toddler, your daughter:

  • Played with the neighborhood kids at their houses.

  • Played at your home with neighborhood kids.

  • Wasn't allowed to play with the neighborhood ruffians.

  • Now, you might have lived in a tough neighborhood, and maybe in that case, you were right to keep your kids at home — alone. But if you were living in a decent area and your main fears were all about what could happen…that's being overprotective.

    2. As children, your kids were in the Emergency Room for:

    • Every cold, fever, and hangnail.

    • Broken bones and deep wounds.

    • You'd never let them into that germ-laden environment.

    Hmm…if you're answering a or c…that's overprotective parenting.

    3. When your daughter first started talking about boys, your reply was:

  • “Boys are bad! Stay away!”

  • A reluctant, “All right…let's hear about these boys.”

  • Your daughter knows better than to bring up the topic around you.

  • Obviously, the only nonoverprotective answer is b.If you tried (a), to steer your daughter away from boys (because you were one once, after all, and you know what they're all about) to the point that (c) she knew better than to even suggest that she had a boyfriend…that's being overprotective.

    4. As a teenager, your daughter was:

  • Rebellious

  • Quiet

  • Right next to you and your wife all the time.

  • If your teenage daughter never left the house, it might be because she was shy or because she was a homebody. But if she was never allowed to leave because you were too afraid of what might happen to her if she did…you were being overprotective.

    5. When your daughter chose a college, you made sure it was:

  • The best you could afford.

  • Able to meet her needs — athletic, artistic, etc.

  • Right around the block. College campuses are dangerous places.

  • While it's completely understandable that you'd want your child to be safe, keeping her at arm's length isn't the only way to do this. In fact, if you've never let her out of your sight, you've kind of set her up for a lifetime of depending on you…which is being overprotective.

    6. In college, your daughter brought home her boyfriends for the weekend.

  • True

  • False

  • Assuming your daughter had a few significant others over the course of her college years, one or two of them probably made an appearance at your dinner table…unless, of course, you made no bones about the fact that college men are only after one thing. That, by the way, is being overprotective.

    7. Your daughter's boyfriend, James, has just asked for your permission to marry her. In response, you said:

  • “Tell me about your plans for the future, Jimbo.”

  • “Get out of my house!”

  • “I gotta tell you, Jim, that you aren't really my daughter's type. She likes much taller, smarter, richer men. So that settles that.”

  • Raking James over the coals a bit (a) is perfectly acceptable, as long as you don't make him cry. Ordering him out of your home (b), or making him feel as though he's not worthy of your princess (c) is being overprotective.

    8. Your daughter is talking about this wonderful man she's met and how she thinks he might be The One. Your first thought:

  • No thoughts. You choose to roll your eyes instead.

  • “He's probably just going to break her heart.”

  • “Great! Look how happy she is!”

  • Answering b? That's being overprotective, considering you haven't met the guy yet. Reserve your judgment until you've sat down and really talked with him. Then you're free to make an honest evaluation of his character.

    9. She's bound and determined to marry this guy. Your last resort is to:

  • Accept it and support her decision.

  • Have him checked out.

  • Pay this guy off so that he leaves town.

  • Having the guy checked out isn't actually that bad — it borders on being insanely overprotective, but if he's given you legitimate reasons to question his character (he freely admits to laundering money, for example), it's not such a crazy thing to do. Paying him off, on the other hand, is a bad move…and it's definitely crossing the line into overprotective territory.

    10. Your daughter has taken her vows, she's back from the honeymoon, and she's in tears. Apparently, she's having second thoughts. You:

  • Clear out her old room and insist that she come home. You were right!

  • Tell her to find her husband and work things out.

  • Hand her over to her mother — you don't know how to handle this.

  • Every marriage has its ups and downs. If you didn't approve of the wedding in the first place, resisting the urge to take care of everything for your emotional daughter is difficult. Chances are, she'll work things out….If you've been shouting, “Leave him! Leave him!” you're going to appear — what's the word? — overprotective.

    1. Home
    2. Father of the Bride
    3. Daddy's Little Girl
    4. A Little Overprotective, Are Ya?
    Visit other About.com sites:

    Netplaces.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

    All rights reserved.